Vertical Marketing System vs. Horizontal Marketing System: What's the Difference?
Edited by Janet White || By Harlon Moss || Published on January 1, 2024
A vertical marketing system (VMS) involves coordinated efforts at different production and distribution stages, while a horizontal marketing system (HMS) integrates activities at the same level across different businesses.
Key Differences
A vertical marketing system (VMS) is a structured model where each stage of production and distribution works under a unifying strategy, typically involving manufacturers, wholesalers, and retailers. In contrast, a horizontal marketing system (HMS) involves collaboration between firms at the same level in the market, such as two retailers or manufacturers, to leverage shared strengths or market reach.
In a vertical marketing system, there's a centralized control, ensuring consistency and efficiency in the supply chain. Businesses collaborate in a top-down approach. On the other hand, a horizontal marketing system promotes partnerships between companies at the same industry level, focusing on achieving mutual goals such as market expansion or shared technology use.
The vertical marketing system often shows a high level of integration, with the possibility of a single company owning multiple levels of its supply chain. This contrasts with the horizontal marketing system, where companies maintain their independence while strategically partnering with others for specific projects or objectives.
Vertical marketing systems are characterized by their ability to control quality and streamline operations from production to sale. Conversely, horizontal marketing systems are marked by their capacity to combine resources, expertise, or customer bases from different companies to tackle market opportunities or challenges.
In vertical marketing systems, the focus is on controlling the product journey, ensuring brand consistency. In horizontal marketing systems, the emphasis lies on leveraging combined strengths to better compete or innovate within the market.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Level of Integration
Integrates different stages of production and distribution
Integrates efforts of businesses at the same stage
Control and Coordination
Centralized, often with top-down control
Collaborative with shared decision-making
Independence of Entities
Often features entities under a single ownership
Entities remain independent but cooperate
Primary Focus
Controlling the supply chain, from production to consumer
Leveraging combined strengths for market reach or innovation
Examples
A retailer owning its manufacturing and distribution
Two retailers collaborating for a joint marketing campaign
ADVERTISEMENT
Vertical Marketing System and Horizontal Marketing System Definitions
Vertical Marketing System
A model of supply chain management with centralized control over multiple stages.
The vertical marketing system allowed the company to control both the making and selling of its products.
Horizontal Marketing System
A model where firms at the same level work together for mutual benefit.
The horizontal marketing system was instrumental in their joint advertising campaign.
Vertical Marketing System
A system where production, distribution, and sale are integrated under a unified strategy.
In a vertical marketing system, a smartphone manufacturer might own its own retail outlets.
Horizontal Marketing System
A system where companies at the same market level collaborate for shared goals.
The horizontal marketing system between the two retailers expanded their collective market reach.
Vertical Marketing System
A coordinated approach to manage the supply chain in a top-down manner.
The vertical marketing system ensured that the brand's vision was consistent at every level.
Horizontal Marketing System
An alliance between similar companies to pool resources or expertise.
The horizontal marketing system enabled both brands to leverage each other's technological innovations.
Vertical Marketing System
A system in which a single company owns or controls multiple steps from production to distribution.
Their vertical marketing system was effective in maintaining quality control across all stages.
Horizontal Marketing System
A partnership strategy among peers in the industry to strengthen market presence.
Their horizontal marketing system was a strategic move to counter competition more effectively.
Vertical Marketing System
A structure where different levels of a product's journey are closely linked.
The company's vertical marketing system streamlined the process from factory to storefront.
Horizontal Marketing System
A collaborative effort between businesses at the same stage of production or distribution.
Through a horizontal marketing system, the companies jointly launched a new product line.
FAQs
What's an advantage of a vertical marketing system?
It ensures consistent brand messaging and efficient supply chain management.
How does a horizontal marketing system work?
It involves collaboration between companies at the same level, like two manufacturers, to achieve common objectives.
Do companies in a horizontal marketing system lose their independence?
No, they maintain their independence but collaborate on specific projects or goals.
What is a vertical marketing system?
It's a coordinated system of managing production, distribution, and sales within a unified strategy, often under single ownership.
What kind of companies typically use a horizontal marketing system?
Companies at the same stage of production or distribution, looking to expand market reach or share resources.
Can a vertical marketing system reduce costs?
Yes, by streamlining operations and reducing intermediaries, it can lower costs.
Can a vertical marketing system control quality?
Yes, it allows for better quality control by managing multiple stages of the product journey.
How does a horizontal marketing system impact competition?
It can enhance competitiveness by combining resources and strengths of different companies.
What are the risks of a vertical marketing system?
Risks include over-reliance on a single supply chain and potential inflexibility in responding to market changes.
What's a key difference in decision-making between the two systems?
Vertical systems often have centralized decision-making, while horizontal systems involve collaborative decisions.
Can a horizontal marketing system help in cost-saving?
Yes, especially in marketing and distribution through shared efforts.
Do vertical marketing systems require large capital investment?
Often yes, due to the need for ownership or control over multiple stages of the supply chain.
How do vertical marketing systems impact customer experience?
They can provide a consistent customer experience by controlling the entire product journey.
Are vertical marketing systems more common in certain industries?
Yes, industries like automotive and electronics often use vertical systems for better control over production and distribution.
How does market dynamics affect the choice between these two systems?
Companies choose based on market needs, competition, and their ability to manage supply chains or collaborate with others.
Why do companies engage in a horizontal marketing system?
To leverage combined strengths and resources for market expansion or innovation.
Is vertical marketing system suitable for small businesses?
It can be challenging for small businesses due to the need for control over multiple supply chain stages.
Can vertical and horizontal marketing systems coexist?
Yes, a company can participate in both, using vertical integration for its products and horizontal strategies for collaborations.
Can horizontal marketing systems quicken product development?
Yes, by pooling expertise and resources, they can accelerate innovation and product development.
How does technology impact horizontal marketing systems?
Technology facilitates collaboration and coordination among companies in a horizontal marketing system.
About Author
Written by
Harlon MossHarlon is a seasoned quality moderator and accomplished content writer for Difference Wiki. An alumnus of the prestigious University of California, he earned his degree in Computer Science. Leveraging his academic background, Harlon brings a meticulous and informed perspective to his work, ensuring content accuracy and excellence.
Edited by
Janet WhiteJanet White has been an esteemed writer and blogger for Difference Wiki. Holding a Master's degree in Science and Medical Journalism from the prestigious Boston University, she has consistently demonstrated her expertise and passion for her field. When she's not immersed in her work, Janet relishes her time exercising, delving into a good book, and cherishing moments with friends and family.
