Open Loop Control System vs. Closed Loop Control System: What's the Difference?
Edited by Aimie Carlson || By Janet White || Published on February 20, 2024
Open loop control systems operate without feedback, executing predefined actions, while closed loop systems adjust actions based on feedback to maintain desired output.
Key Differences
Open loop control systems execute actions based on preset conditions without monitoring the outcome, whereas closed loop control systems continually adjust their actions based on feedback to ensure the desired result is achieved.
The key distinction is the lack of feedback in open loop systems; they don't adjust based on output changes. Closed loop systems, conversely, rely on feedback to constantly adapt and correct their performance.
Open loop systems are generally simpler and less expensive but less reliable for complex tasks. Closed loop systems are more complex and costly but offer greater reliability and precision, especially in dynamic environments.
An open loop system example is a conventional toaster, which operates for a set time regardless of the toast's actual condition. A thermostat, a closed loop system, adjusts heating based on the room's temperature.
Open loop systems are suitable for simple, well-defined tasks, while closed loop systems are better for tasks requiring high precision and adaptability to changing conditions.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comparison Chart
Feedback
No feedback mechanism
Uses feedback for control
Complexity
Simpler, less complex
More complex
Cost
Generally less expensive
More expensive
Reliability
Less reliable for complex tasks
Highly reliable
Examples
Conventional toasters, manual washing machines
Thermostats, automatic washing machines
ADVERTISEMENT
Open Loop Control System and Closed Loop Control System Definitions
Open Loop Control System
They follow a predetermined sequence without adapting to external changes.
A conventional oven that cooks at a set temperature for a fixed duration is an open loop control system.
Closed Loop Control System
These systems are dynamic, reacting to output changes for precise control.
A thermostat maintaining a room at a set temperature is a closed loop control system.
Open Loop Control System
Open loop systems execute fixed operations without monitoring the result.
An electric kettle that switches off after a certain time is an example of an open loop control system.
Closed Loop Control System
A closed loop control system adjusts its operations based on feedback to achieve desired outcomes.
A car's cruise control, which adjusts speed based on external conditions, is a closed loop control system.
Open Loop Control System
An open loop control system operates on preset instructions without reacting to output changes.
A washing machine that runs for a set time regardless of clothes' cleanliness is an open loop control system.
Closed Loop Control System
Closed loop systems are ideal for complex tasks requiring high accuracy.
An autopilot system in aircraft, adjusting to wind conditions, exemplifies a closed loop control system.
Open Loop Control System
These systems are simpler and often used where high precision is not critical.
Automatic lawn sprinklers working on a timer represent an open loop control system.
Closed Loop Control System
These systems are more complex and expensive but offer greater precision.
A modern factory robot that adjusts its actions based on sensory input is a closed loop control system.
Open Loop Control System
Open loop systems are cost-effective but may not be ideal for fluctuating conditions.
A light that turns on at sunset and off at sunrise, regardless of actual light conditions, is an open loop control system.
Closed Loop Control System
They continuously monitor and adjust operations based on real-time data.
An insulin pump that adjusts dosage based on blood sugar levels is a closed loop control system.
FAQs
What is an open loop control system?
It's a control system that operates on predefined instructions without using feedback to adjust its actions.
Where are open loop systems commonly used?
They're used in simple, predictable environments where high precision isn't crucial, like in basic household appliances.
What is a closed loop control system?
A closed loop system adjusts its operations based on feedback to achieve or maintain a desired output.
Can open loop systems handle unpredictable environments?
Generally, no. They lack the feedback mechanism to adapt to unforeseen changes.
Can an open loop system be upgraded to a closed loop?
Yes, but it requires adding feedback mechanisms and possibly more complex control algorithms.
What makes closed loop systems more reliable?
Their ability to continuously adjust based on feedback makes them reliable, especially in complex and changing conditions.
Are open loop systems easier to maintain?
Yes, due to their simplicity, they are usually easier and less costly to maintain.
Why are closed loop systems more expensive?
Their complexity and the need for feedback mechanisms and sensors increase their cost.
Are closed loop systems used in vehicles?
Yes, examples include anti-lock braking systems and cruise control.
Is an autopilot a closed loop system?
Yes, it continuously adjusts the plane's course based on various feedback.
Is a thermostat an example of a closed loop system?
Yes, as it adjusts heating or cooling based on the room's temperature.
Do closed loop systems require sophisticated software?
Typically, yes, to process feedback and make real-time adjustments.
How do closed loop systems handle error correction?
They use feedback to detect errors and adjust operations to correct them.
How do closed loop systems improve accuracy?
By constantly monitoring and adjusting based on real-time feedback, they maintain high accuracy.
What's a simple example of an open loop system?
A basic electric toaster that runs for a set time is a simple open loop system.
Can weather systems be predicted using open loop systems?
No, due to the unpredictability and complexity of weather, closed loop systems are more suitable.
Are open loop systems suitable for safety-critical applications?
Generally, no, as they lack the ability to adapt to unexpected situations.
Do open loop systems require user intervention?
Often they do, especially if conditions change or if precision is needed.
Can open loop systems be energy efficient?
Yes, but their efficiency might be compromised if conditions vary significantly.
Is a washing machine a closed loop system?
Modern washing machines with sensors to adjust the cycle based on load are closed loop systems.
About Author
Written by
Janet WhiteJanet White has been an esteemed writer and blogger for Difference Wiki. Holding a Master's degree in Science and Medical Journalism from the prestigious Boston University, she has consistently demonstrated her expertise and passion for her field. When she's not immersed in her work, Janet relishes her time exercising, delving into a good book, and cherishing moments with friends and family.
Edited by
Aimie CarlsonAimie Carlson, holding a master's degree in English literature, is a fervent English language enthusiast. She lends her writing talents to Difference Wiki, a prominent website that specializes in comparisons, offering readers insightful analyses that both captivate and inform.
