Heck Reaction vs. Stile Reaction: What's the Difference?
Edited by Aimie Carlson || By Janet White || Published on September 6, 2024
The Heck reaction is a palladium-catalyzed coupling between aryl halides and alkenes to form substituted alkenes. The Stille reaction is a palladium-catalyzed coupling between organotin compounds and organic electrophiles to form carbon-carbon bonds.
Key Differences
The Heck reaction and the Stille reaction are both palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions, but they differ in their reactants and applications. The Heck reaction involves the coupling of aryl halides or vinyl halides with alkenes in the presence of a base and a palladium catalyst to form substituted alkenes. The Stille reaction, on the other hand, involves the coupling of organotin compounds with organic electrophiles, such as aryl halides, to form carbon-carbon bonds.
Both reactions have their own advantages and limitations. The Heck reaction is favored for its ability to directly form carbon-carbon double bonds, while the Stille reaction is appreciated for its versatility and tolerance of sensitive functional groups. However, the use of toxic organotin reagents in the Stille reaction is a major drawback, leading to concerns about environmental and health safety.
The Heck and Stille reactions are important tools in organic synthesis, each with its own unique features and applications. The choice between the two depends on the specific requirements of the synthesis, such as the nature of the substrates and the desired products.
Comparison Chart
Reactants
Aryl halides or vinyl halides, alkenes
Organotin compounds, organic electrophiles (e.g., aryl halides)
Product
Substituted alkenes
Carbon-carbon bond formation
ADVERTISEMENT
Catalyst
Palladium
Palladium
Advantages
Direct formation of C=C bonds, wide substrate scope
Versatility, tolerance of sensitive functional groups
Limitations
Sometimes requires harsh conditions
Use of toxic organotin reagents
Heck Reaction and Stile Reaction Definitions
Heck Reaction
The Heck reaction can be applied to various aryl halides and alkenes.
Different aryl halides were screened in the Heck reaction to optimize the yield of the desired product.
Stile Reaction
The Stille reaction is useful in the synthesis of complex organic molecules.
A key step in the total synthesis of the natural product involved a Stille reaction.
ADVERTISEMENT
Heck Reaction
The Heck reaction forms carbon-carbon double bonds.
A key intermediate in the drug synthesis was obtained through a Heck reaction.
Stile Reaction
The Stille reaction requires a palladium catalyst and a phosphine ligand.
The choice of phosphine ligand in the Stille reaction significantly affected the reaction rate.
Heck Reaction
The Heck reaction is a palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling reaction between aryl halides and alkenes.
The Heck reaction was used to synthesize the substituted alkene in the final step of the natural product synthesis.
Stile Reaction
The Stille reaction can couple substrates that are sensitive to harsh conditions.
The Stille reaction was chosen for its ability to couple substrates without affecting the labile functional groups.
Heck Reaction
The Heck reaction requires a base and a palladium catalyst.
The choice of base and palladium catalyst is crucial for the success of the Heck reaction.
Stile Reaction
The Stille reaction is a palladium-catalyzed coupling between organotin compounds and organic electrophiles.
The Stille reaction was employed to form the carbon-carbon bond in the molecule.
Heck Reaction
The Heck reaction is widely used in organic synthesis.
The versatility of the Heck reaction makes it a valuable tool in the synthesis of complex molecules.
Stile Reaction
The Stille reaction is known for its versatility in coupling a wide range of substrates.
Sensitive functional groups were preserved during the Stille reaction, demonstrating its mild reaction conditions.
FAQs
What are the advantages of the Stille reaction?
The Stille reaction is valued for its versatility, ability to couple a wide range of substrates, and tolerance of sensitive functional groups.
What are the limitations of the Stille reaction?
The main limitation of the Stille reaction is the use of toxic organotin reagents, which raises environmental and health concerns.
What is the Heck reaction?
The Heck reaction is a palladium-catalyzed cross-coupling between aryl halides and alkenes to form substituted alkenes.
What is the Stille reaction?
The Stille reaction is a palladium-catalyzed coupling between organotin compounds and organic electrophiles to form carbon-carbon bonds.
What are the key differences between the Heck and Stille reactions?
The key differences lie in their reactants (aryl halides and alkenes for Heck, organotin compounds and electrophiles for Stille) and their products (substituted alkenes for Heck, carbon-carbon bonds for Stille).
What are the limitations of the Heck reaction?
The Heck reaction sometimes requires harsh conditions, which may not be suitable for sensitive substrates.
What types of products can be synthesized using the Stille reaction?
The Stille reaction is used to synthesize a wide variety of organic compounds, including complex natural products, pharmaceuticals, and materials with carbon-carbon bonds.
What are the advantages of the Heck reaction?
The Heck reaction is advantageous for directly forming carbon-carbon double bonds and its wide substrate scope.
Can the Heck reaction be used with aliphatic alkenes?
Yes, the Heck reaction can be used with both aliphatic and aromatic alkenes, although the reactivity may vary depending on the substrate.
Can the Stille reaction be used with alkyl halides?
The Stille reaction is generally used with aryl halides, but it can also be used with alkyl halides under certain conditions.
What role does the base play in the Heck reaction?
The base in the Heck reaction is used to deprotonate the alkene, facilitating its nucleophilic attack on the palladium-aryl complex.
How is the palladium catalyst used in the Stille reaction?
In the Stille reaction, the palladium catalyst forms a complex with the organotin compound, which then reacts with the organic electrophile to form the carbon-carbon bond.
How is the palladium catalyst used in the Heck reaction?
In the Heck reaction, the palladium catalyst facilitates the formation of a palladium complex with the aryl halide, which then reacts with the alkene to form the substituted alkene.
What types of products can be synthesized using the Heck reaction?
The Heck reaction is commonly used to synthesize substituted alkenes, which are important intermediates in the synthesis of natural products, pharmaceuticals, and other complex molecules.
What are the environmental concerns associated with the Stille reaction?
The environmental concerns associated with the Stille reaction mainly stem from the use of toxic organotin reagents, which can be harmful to both human health and the environment.
What are some common palladium catalysts used in the Stille reaction?
Common palladium catalysts used in the Stille reaction include palladium(II) acetate, palladium(II) chloride, and palladium(0) complexes with phosphine ligands.
What role do phosphine ligands play in the Stille reaction?
Phosphine ligands in the Stille reaction stabilize the palladium catalyst and can influence the reactivity and selectivity of the reaction.
How can the selectivity of the Heck reaction be controlled?
The selectivity of the Heck reaction can be controlled through the choice of catalyst, ligands, base, and reaction conditions.
How can the selectivity of the Stille reaction be controlled?
The selectivity of the Stille reaction can be controlled through the choice of palladium catalyst, phosphine ligands, and reaction conditions.
What are some common palladium catalysts used in the Heck reaction?
Common palladium catalysts used in the Heck reaction include palladium acetate, palladium(II) chloride, and palladium(0) complexes.
About Author
Written by
Janet WhiteJanet White has been an esteemed writer and blogger for Difference Wiki. Holding a Master's degree in Science and Medical Journalism from the prestigious Boston University, she has consistently demonstrated her expertise and passion for her field. When she's not immersed in her work, Janet relishes her time exercising, delving into a good book, and cherishing moments with friends and family.
Edited by
Aimie CarlsonAimie Carlson, holding a master's degree in English literature, is a fervent English language enthusiast. She lends her writing talents to Difference Wiki, a prominent website that specializes in comparisons, offering readers insightful analyses that both captivate and inform.
